Andy Borgmann's Blog
Where The Producer Gets the Mic
Next: Will You Marry Me? Probably Not. Previous: I Wish I Was 14
The Cost of Education
The Cost of Education - One Private School Students AccountThis week was a great week. Why? Because I paid off my $11,000 student loan. After 15 months, I had accumulated $517.45 in interest, and averaged $767.83 a month in payments. For the first time in 4 years, I have no debt to my name, and it feels great.

But I am a nerd and I didn't stop there. Now that I know exactly how much I paid in interest, I, of course, consulted my Quicken to figure out just how much college cost me.

Now there are some out there that could careless, and that's cool. Just stop reading. It's alright. But I find this fascinating and I think in the end it will have a point ;)

For the four years between 6/1/01 and 5/5/05 (plus interest afterwards related to student loan) my expenses were as followed:

  • Direct Education: $91,411.09 (tuition, books, fees, educational travel & student loan interest)
  • Room or Rent: $16,198.04 (both on and off-campus housing)
  • Food: $13,244.59 (board, groceries, and dining out)
  • Utilities: $3,984.94 (gas, water, electricity, cell phone)
  • Tithe & Non-Profit Giving: $5,030.75
  • Other Expenses: $18,802.33 (taxes, travel, auto fuel, etc...)
  • Total Expenses: $148,671.84


Holy cow! Direct expenses only relating to my education was $91,411.09, and once you include living expenses like eating and having an apartment/dorm the sum was $148,671.84. Now, lets see how the bills were paid:

  • Dividend Income: $70.56
  • Savings Interest: $173.08
  • Gifts from Others: $2,365.61 (mainly high school graduation & "Charlie's travel gifts")
  • Investment Income: $4,4710.44 (GE Stock)
  • Mom: $5,341.54 ($5,016.54 was for Summer of '01 and Freshman year)
  • Grandma Borgmann Gift: $10,000
  • Scholarships: $20,275.00
  • Dad: $26,500.25
  • Salary Earned from Working During College: $27,698.84
  • Grandma Neslund Gift: $40,000
  • Total Income: 137,135.32


The income/expense difference was $11,536.42, and after you subtract out $11,000 in student loan and the $517.45 in interest related to the loan, that left a "real college debt" of $18.97.

Now, I could take this is so many different ways, and I am going to try to hit them all.

First of all, it all was worth it. APU prepared me for the real world and my profession better than any university I can imagine. Even at the stark cost of almost $150k (that's a freakin' house in Indiana), it was still worth it.

Second of all, I spent a good chunk of college complaining about how little my dad paid. Now I always say this with a disclaimer that I recognize that I am incredibly blessed in life - I cannot overstate that. But my dad was kind of "mathematical" in his approach to paying for my college. He took Indiana University's tuition (which was $12,000) in 2001. He then took 2/3 of that ($8,0000), as he figured each parent is responsible for 1/3 and so is the student. Then he divided his income in 2001 by his income and my mom's income (which came to 78.1%). He then applied this number to the $8,000 and WAM, dad's contribution was $6250.00 a year (although admittedly senior year he paid an extra $1,500 for an average contribution of $6,625). What always irked me about dad is he had this sort of "you got to earn this for yourself" attitude, but he had all of his private college and law school paid for by his parents.

BUT, all that to say, I am grateful that he contributed what he did, because I know a lot of people out there who would have loved to have had half of what he contributed, and for that I am blessed. Which is lesson number two: I am very grateful for all of those who sacrificed for my education and I do not tread lightly on the idea that while I paid more than $40,000 of my own education, there was still $110,000 that came from elsewhere.

My third point is this: debt! Debt sucks. I hate debt probably more than most (hence the reason I have no savings right now besides a 401(k) but I have no debt). But still, the average student leaving college has $19,000 in debt (and if you are in private school like me and my alumni, it is far worse).

Debt when used correctly is a good thing (school, house, etc...). But even when it is a good thing, it is still a bad thing. As talk radio host (and friend of our show) Dave Ramsey says:
Debt is not a tool; it is a method to make banks wealthy, not you. Debt is dumb. Most normal people are just plain broke because they are in debt up to their eyeballs with no hope of help. If you're in debt then you're a slave, in the sense that you do not have the freedom to use your money to help change your family tree. According to a recent USA Today article about debt, 78 percent of baby boomers have mortgage debt, 59 percent have credit card debt, 56 percent have car payments.


The point is, get out of debt as fast as you can. Don't buy into the lie of "good debt."

It was a great four years of college. It was worth the extra 15 months of paying for it, but I am very releaved to be out form under it. I am glad I can now look onto the horizon as I look towards taking my next $140k venture of buying a place ;) (although I am still not sure if that makes sense).
Comments
Sarah
Saturday, March 31, 2007 10:27:34 AM    Quote Selection | Permalink
Gravatar.com you make me laugh - congrats on paying off the monster - I'm super jealous!


Andy Borgmann
Saturday, March 31, 2007 10:44:10 AM    Quote Selection | Permalink
Gravatar.com
Quoted From: Sarah [Visitor]I'm super jealous!
Yeah, but you're getting married in like 15 days to someone you love, so I am super jealous of you ;)



Andrew Howard
Saturday, March 31, 2007 04:46:12 PM    Quote Selection | Permalink
Gravatar.com I think you may have slightly miscalculated the true cost of your education.

What about the enormous opportunity cost of attending college. Put that $50,000 from your grandparents into a low-risk interest baring saving account (~5%), a CD (~6%), or the stock market (~13%) and you are looking at a lot of money.

Not to mention that you have to include what you could have been making had you simply worked for four years (minus living expenses).

College education is definitly worth it; however, it is _very_expensive.

I personally believe that there is such thing as "good debt" - but my definition doesn't include much (i.e. Mortgages only). Most people cannot afford to pay for a house outright, thus we must go into debt to buy one. Otherwise, we effectively walk outside and set our $600 on fire each month for rent. A house allows you to build equity and, in most cases, if you become in financial trouble, you can sell it and earn back all, if not more, than you spent.

The problem is that most people buy more than they can afford. Live below your means - thats my philosophy.


Andy Borgmann
Saturday, March 31, 2007 09:00:33 PM    Quote Selection | Permalink
Gravatar.com
Quoted From: Andrew Howard [Visitor]What about the enormous opportunity cost of attending college.
Yeah, but if you are going to go that route, then I would have to figure in the opportunity loss of not attending college. Since studies prove that those who graduate college make far more money in the span of a lifetime than those who don't, it would essentially mean for this discussion that college didn't cost me anything and would actually have made me money. Thus, I decided to just stick with actual cash inflow/outflow during the time span of being in college.



Andrea
Sunday, April 1, 2007 08:00:10 AM    Quote Selection | Permalink
Gravatar.com Good thing you paid that off because I have a feel that you are going to have to get a new car soon.....which = a new loan. I mean, how many more times can your Honda make it to Indiana?


Andy Borgmann
Sunday, April 1, 2007 08:34:18 AM    Quote Selection | Permalink
Gravatar.com
Quoted From: Andrea [Visitor]I mean, how many more times can your Honda make it to Indiana?
Tell me about it. That sucker has made it 191,000 with no problems. Although I think before the next trip to Indiana I will have to get it checked out. I am really hoping it lasts me until next Summer (of '08). Then we'll have had it for 10 years. But I am dreading the car loan that's for sure. But I can start saving for it now, and then with the trade in value hopefully have less than 10,000 grand in a car loan.

Ohh and I told you, the next time I am coming to Indiana I am flying in on my own plane (ok, not my own plane, but on one I rent ;) )


Andrea
Sunday, April 1, 2007 08:41:52 PM    Quote Selection | Permalink
Gravatar.com You said: Then we'll have had it for 10 years.....

who exactly is we'll?


Andy Borgmann
Sunday, April 1, 2007 10:43:43 PM    Quote Selection | Permalink
Gravatar.com
Quoted From: Andrea [Visitor]who exactly is we'll?
Me and my imaginary wife. Nahh, just kidding, even an imaginary wife wouldn't be as good as you.

My mom owned it for the first year, and then I will have owned it for the last nine years. So we, collectively, will ahve owned it for 10 years ;)



DEBTective
Monday, April 2, 2007 02:24:03 PM    Quote Selection | Permalink
Gravatar.com Big-time proud of you, bub, for deep-sixing your student loan debt. Thanks for spreading the word about being debt-free. Let's get everyone else to catch the fever, baby!


Join the Discussion and Post A Comment
Name:
Email Address
(mandatory - always private
also will be used for gravatar)
:
Website/Blog (optional):
(Standard HTML Tags allowed - a,b,blockquote,br,code,i,li,ol,ul - abusers will be logged and blocked)

What's Andy Up To?

Description
Andy is the Executive Producer of The Allen Hunt Show; a progressive, talk radio show based in Atlanta, GA aimed at bringing faith back into the public discussion. Andy enjoys travel, aviation, web design, politics, friends, and faith. He holds that the secret to a full life is loving God and loving people - which he fails at constantly.

Andy's blog is a place to discuss religion, politics, ministry, education, and well, just life - especially focused on the time of life we call our 20s! It is cross-post at The Allen Hunt Show, and, in a more limited fashion, at Newsvine.

Andy grew up in Fort Wayne, IN. He now lives in Alpharetta, GA.

More information about Andy can be found at www.2timothy42.org or Andy's Virb.

P.S. As has been mentioned on air, Andy is horrible at grammar and spelling. Please excuse any mistakes, trust me, he's sorry.


RSS
Posts: RSS 2.0 | Atom
Google Reader
Comments:
     RSS 2.0 | Atom

Email Subscribe

Powered by FeedBurner


Calendar
<<    <    Mar 2007    >    >>
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31